The Critic as Artist


Posted by Michael Happy on December 14th, 2009

wilde

One of Frye’s favorite critics, Oscar Wilde, observed, “All bad art is the result of good intentions.”

I think Frye makes it clear enough that all bad criticism arises from the same impulse.  Literature, for example, does not possess intention in any ideological sense, despite the fact that most “literary” critics have more or less assumed that it does.  What literature possesses is concern, which is not intentional but prophetic.  The fatalism of ideological criticism is its failure.

That is all.

2 Responses to “The Critic as Artist”

  1. Bob Garlitz Says:

    Great comment. Terrific distinction. Why didn’t someone tell me this twenty–or more—years ago. ? :) (Ignorance of Frye is no excuse.)

  2. Literature prophetic, Ideology fatalistic « bobgarlitz Says:

    [...] love this whole post.  It is by Michael Happy, posted on the website The Educated Imagination, devoted to the work of Northrop [...]

Leave a Reply